• What we do
  • The People
  • About Us
  • Why Innovation Africa
  • Contact Us
Innovation AfricaCreating the Future Today
  • Feature Articles
  • Innovation
  • Agriculture
  • ICT
  • Technology
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Health
  • Store
  • Contact Us
Menu
  • Feature Articles
  • Innovation
  • Agriculture
  • ICT
  • Technology
  • Entrepreneurship
  • Health
  • Store
  • Contact Us
  • MERL Tech Lessons Not Learned in International Development

    November 4, 2015 Editor 0

    decades of water sanitation commitments

    The world has made several commitments to water and sanitation, starting as far back as the 1970s, and leading up to the recent Sustainable Development Goals. Also over the past few decades, the development of the internet and cool data collection tools has enabled more and more organizations to share their evaluations and monitoring data publicly.

    But is anyone actually learning from them?

    Four years ago, I founded Improve International to address sustainability issues in water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH). Since then, I’ve been reading a lot of evaluations, research, and systematic reviews, some as old as the 1970s. One great resource is Watering White Elephants: lessons from donor funded planning and implementation of rural water supplies in Tanzania from 1988.

    major decade constraints in developing countries

    What I’ve noticed is that, in the WASH sector, we’ve been producing the same “lessons learned” for 40 plus years. Some of the lessons re-learned throughout the past four decades were summarized in Watering White Elephants. Others include:

    • No more business as usual. It is now business as usual to say this.
    • Long-term follow up is really important to get behavior changes to stick.
    • It’s not about the infrastructure; it’s about the services.
    • Isolated rural communities will have a hard time managing their own water services over time.

    The sustainable development goals have us committed to UNIVERSAL sanitation and water. It’s time for us to stop reinventing the flat tire.

    Why aren’t lessons learned?

    Perhaps they are learned, but they don’t seem to be acted upon. I think the main reason for this is there is little accountability in the sector. Think about this: How many charity organizations do you know that have gone out of business because of bad results? How many foundations? Can a customer (aka beneficiary) call up the charitable organization or the donor and say their water point isn’t working?

    Why do we need to learn from the past? Some people ask, aren’t good intentions enough? No. Bad development is doing harm. Failed water and sanitation services make poor people poorer, impact their health, and make behavior change even harder. We have a moral imperative to work smarter.

    How can we really change? I have three ideas: independent ratings, design for action, and sharing is caring.

    1. Independent ratings

    Rather than just doing a bunch of separate monitoring and evaluation efforts, what if have independent rating of effectiveness based on actual results? There are a few examples we can learn from:

    • In the UK PQASSO is a performance evaluation system and quality mark for charitable organizations.
    • The Water for Life Rating has been applied in Honduras, Nicaragua, and Bangladesh.
    • GiveWell does in-depth research aiming to determine how much good a given program accomplishes per dollar spent.

    There is money for this! GiveWell just got $25 million grant.

    2. Design for action

    A recent report from ITAD on “How to strengthen ICTs for monitoring to improve the sustainability of water services?” found that:

    • ICT reporting is more likely to be successful if it is service-provider or government -led compared to crowd-sourcing. Can we get everyone working in a country together to support country-wide or regional services monitoring systems? SIASAR in Central America is a great example.
    • Water service repairs are more likely to occur if the ICT initiative has a built-in maintenance model. Can we make tech part of a service delivery system rather stand-alone?

    3. Sharing is caring

    Can we work toward agreeing on and incorporating more common monitoring indicators so that data can be shared? The Water Point Data Exchange made some great progress on this.

    A Call to Action

    So here is my call to action: You can design MERL Tech to collect & share data for action and learning. Keep in mind:

    • Monitor ongoing services, not just the project. We need more than random snapshots of functionality.
    • Plan Evaluation to be used as diagnosis not an autopsy. If we are about saving lives, we need to use evaluations for resolution of problems and reform.
    • Research should be designed and used for change, not just conference presentations.
    • Learning should come before and after programs. Let’s fail forward fearlessly and make new mistakes, not repeat the old ones.

    In fact, my challenge to you is to come up with a new WASH failure that we haven’t identified in our literature search. I’ll give a $25 Amex gift card for the first person who leaves a comment on ICTworks with documentation of the new failure (deadline November 15).

    Just remember, it’s important to learn and act on lessons, because it’s okay to reinvent the wheel, not to reinvent the flat tire.

    By Susan Davis, Executive Director, Improve International

    Go to SourceReprinted from ICTWorks

    Related Posts

    • Science, Technology and Innovation Management: Contributions to a Methodological FrameworkScience, Technology and Innovation Management: Contributions to a Methodological Framework
    • Biases and debiasing in bank lending decisions to nascent entrepreneurs – an experimental studyBiases and debiasing in bank lending decisions to nascent entrepreneurs – an experimental study
    • Pilot test on growing mushrooms and generating biogas from sisal wastePilot test on growing mushrooms and generating biogas from sisal waste
    • Uganda: Oil Analysis Lab for UgandaUganda: Oil Analysis Lab for Uganda
    • Emerging economies alter global innovation landscapeEmerging economies alter global innovation landscape
    • Managing Stakeholders in Team-Based Innovation: The Dynamics of Knowledge and Trust Networks
    Sovrn
    Share

    Categories: ICT

    Will Outernet Bring Connectivity to the Unconnected Parts of the World? Bringing wheat, potato and faba bean seeds to market in the Ethiopian Highlands

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

Subscribe to our stories


 

Recent Posts

  • Entrepreneurial Alertness, Innovation Modes, And Business Models in Small- And Medium-Sized Enterprises December 30, 2021
  • The Strategic Role of Design in Driving Digital Innovation June 10, 2021
  • Correction to: Hybrid mosquitoes? Evidence from rural Tanzania on how local communities conceptualize and respond to modified mosquitoes as a tool for malaria control June 10, 2021
  • BRIEF FOCUS: Optimal spacing for groundnuts in smallholder farming systems June 9, 2021
  • COVID-19 pandemic: impacts on the achievements of Sustainable Development Goals in Africa June 9, 2021

Categories

Archives

Popular Post-All time

  • A review on biomass-based... 1k views
  • Apply Now: $500,000 for Y... 834 views
  • Can blockchain disrupt ge... 816 views
  • Test Your Value Propositi... 779 views
  • Prize-winning projects pr... 740 views

Recent Posts

  • Entrepreneurial Alertness, Innovation Modes, And Business Models in Small- And Medium-Sized Enterprises
  • The Strategic Role of Design in Driving Digital Innovation
  • Correction to: Hybrid mosquitoes? Evidence from rural Tanzania on how local communities conceptualize and respond to modified mosquitoes as a tool for malaria control
  • BRIEF FOCUS: Optimal spacing for groundnuts in smallholder farming systems
  • COVID-19 pandemic: impacts on the achievements of Sustainable Development Goals in Africa
  • Explicit knowledge networks and their relationship with productivity in SMEs
  • Intellectual property issues in artificial intelligence: specific reference to the service sector
  • Africa RISING publishes a livestock feed and forage production manual for Ethiopia
  • Transforming crop residues into a precious feed resource for small ruminants in northern Ghana
  • Photo report: West Africa project partners cap off 2020 with farmers field day events in Northern Ghana and Southern Mali

Tag Cloud

    africa African Agriculture Business Business model Business_Finance Company Crowdsourcing data Development East Africa economics Education Entrepreneur entrepreneurs Entrepreneurship ethiopia ghana Health_Medical_Pharma ict Information technology Innovation kenya knowledge Knowledge Management Leadership marketing mobile Mobile phone nigeria Open innovation Organization Research rwanda science Science and technology studies social enterprise social entrepreneurship south africa Strategic management strategy tanzania Technology Technology_Internet uganda

Categories

Archives

  • A review on biomass-based hydrogen production for renewable energy supply 1k views
  • Apply Now: $500,000 for Your Big Data Innovations in Agriculture 834 views
  • Can blockchain disrupt gender inequality? 816 views
  • Test Your Value Proposition: Supercharge Lean Startup and CustDev Principles 779 views
  • Prize-winning projects promote healthier eating, smarter crop investments 740 views

Copyright © 2005-2020 Innovation Africa Theme created by PWT. Powered by WordPress.org