Why Radical Transparency Is Good Business
October 14, 2012 Editor 0
Imagine you got to work on Monday and you knew exactly how you had performed the previous week, compared to everyone else, and could look up, in a moment, how everyone else was doing. Or a manager could go online, any time of the day or night, and see how his team was performing, who deserved a bonus, who was lagging, even if those people were customer service staff, or engineers. It would make everyone crazy, right?
Radical transparency, the idea of everyone knowing everything, could actually be a major driver of increased organizational performance. Private research software firm Qualtrics believes that the biggest reason companies fail is because people lose focus and get off track. It’s particularly true of young, fast-growing companies driving to meet stretch revenue goals and keep their investors happy. Qualtrics didn’t want to fall into that trap so the company made the bold decision to make all employees’ performance data available to everyone in the company. By doing so, Qualtrics removes the distractions, fears, and negativity that sap concentration. The entire workforce has access to a host of information about the performance and practice of each employee that includes:
- quarterly objectives and results in detail including revenue and satisfaction targets;
- weekly snippets of each individual’s goals for the week;
- up to the minute performance reviews, ratings, and bonus structures;
- noted successes and failures, with notes for everyone to learn from;
- career history at Qualtrics
Insights from neuroscience underscore that our brains work best when we no longer feel the need to hide, cover up our mistakes, or dwell on errors. We do better when we aren’t mentally bogged down in “threat response” worrying about which of our colleagues is the boss’ “flavor of the month,” getting a hasty promotion, or badmouthing our work.
The principles of radical transparency improve business performance in terms of focus, engagement, and growing and recruiting talent. Here’s a preview of how they work:
1. Focus: At the beginning of each quarter, every Qualtrics employee sets measurable and visible objectives and key results (aka OKRs). Each individual’s progress and priorities are clear. This helps reduce the noise and clutter that can overload our prefrontal cortex with a sense of being “overwhelmed” about what our goals are.
2. Engagement: Radical transparency increases commitment and motivation to the corporate mission because employee data are explicitly linked to performance, ensuring high levels of fairness. A sense of real fairness turns out to be deeply rewarding to the brain, especially compared to a sense of unfairness that pervades many employees’ darker thoughts, which activates a strong threat response. Everyone is benchmarked, all data are available for inspection and analysis, and all employees are treated accordingly. The reward response leads to increased engagement, from the strong sense of autonomy the approach brings about, defined as a sense of control over one’s destiny.
3. Growing Talent: By making the successes of top performers accessible and easy to compare against the department or company as a whole, newer employees at Qualtrics are motivated to excel through mirroring the best practices of high-performing employees. This mirroring is extremely powerful in encouraging positive work performance. Another a big plus is that the right people get the promotions, meaning the people who are really consistently performing are rewarded, not the people just good at getting others to think they perform well.
Qualtrics knows that the transparency process creates winners and losers, and that environment can be tough for someone who is not an “A” player. As Marc Effron of the Talent Strategy Group reports from his global consulting work, there’s a pervasive, irrational fear of transparency in corporations worldwide when it comes to talent issues. Many leaders seem concerned that engagement will crater when everyone is told the truth about their potential to advance. While there may be some rough moments, Effron tells clients, here’s the fundamental question: How long do you feel it’s appropriate to lie to your employees about their future?
Effron holds that many executives are far more ready for stronger transparency measures than their HR colleagues suspect. If that’s true, they should check out radical transparency.
The authors will be presenting these ideas and more at the Neuroleadership Summit later this month, with Marc Effron also on the panel.
- Too Much Of A Good Thing? Absorptive Capacity, Firm Performance, And The Moderating Role Of Entrepreneurial Orientation
- Leadership succession and firm performance in an emerging economy: Successor origin, relational embeddedness, and legitimacy
- Linking Knowledge Processes with Firm Performance: Organizational Culture
- The impact of outside-in open innovation on innovation performance
- Pivot East 2013 Winners
- Open Innovation: Three Examples
Subscribe to our stories
- The Strategic Role of Design in Driving Digital Innovation June 10, 2021
- Correction to: Hybrid mosquitoes? Evidence from rural Tanzania on how local communities conceptualize and respond to modified mosquitoes as a tool for malaria control June 10, 2021
- BRIEF FOCUS: Optimal spacing for groundnuts in smallholder farming systems June 9, 2021
- COVID-19 pandemic: impacts on the achievements of Sustainable Development Goals in Africa June 9, 2021
- Explicit knowledge networks and their relationship with productivity in SMEs May 30, 2021